Below is the article which appeared in the Dog’s Naturally Magazine in 2011 that I wrote with my colleague at the time, Dr. Kim Bloomer.
There are still a lot of people who mistakingly beleive that feeding raw meat and bones to their dogs can be hazardoud to their dog’s health and could give them a deadly case of salmonella poisioning.
Know the facts!
Every dog, (and human for that matter), has both “good” and “bad” bacteria in their intestines as part of its normal intestinal
ecology. In order for the immune system to function well, the good bacteria or “probiotics” (translated meaning -“for life”) should typically make up eighty percent of the intestinal flora. The “bad” bacteria (including naturally occurring salmonella and e.coli, etc.), will then make up the remaining twenty percent of the intestinal flora. Dogs, being opportunistic carnivores, designed to eat things that we humans shudder at the thought of, have gastrointestinal tracts which are designed with many unique features that prevent pathogenic bacteria such as salmonella and e.coli from taking over their body and upsetting the healthy balance of intestinal flora.
Salmonella, the Bad Bacteria
By: Jeannie Thomason VND & Kim Bloomer VND
In 2007 we all witnessed the most significant pet food recall in the history of commercial pet food. Since that incident, more and more pet owners are taking interest in what their pets eat. Attention to pet food, treat and product recalls is a very serious part of responsible pet ownership. The most common cause of dog food recalls over the years has been due to salmonella contamination. The center for disease control (CDC), The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the US department of Agriculture (USDA) advise that salmonella can cause potential harm to humans handling these tainted pet products and may cause possible harm to pets. Consequently, pet owners are now keenly aware of what is in fact, a naturally occurring bacteria which carries less risk for their dogs than what they may fear.
Good and Bad Bacteria
Every dog, (and human for that matter), has both “good” and “bad” bacteria in their intestines as part of its normal intestinal ecology. In order for the immune system to function well, the good bacteria or “probiotics” (translated meaning – “for life”) should typically make up eighty percent of the intestinal flora. The “bad” bacteria (including naturally occurring salmonella and e.coli), will then make up the remaining twenty percent of the intestinal flora. Dogs, being opportunistic carnivores, designed to eat things we humans shudder at the thought of, have gastrointestinal tracts which are designed with many unique features that prevent pathogenic bacteria such as salmonella and e.coli from taking over their body and upsetting the healthy balance of intestinal flora.
A dog’s saliva, while lacking in Amylase to begin the digestion process like an omnivore has, instead contains enzymes whose properties neutralize bacteria and help prevent harmful pathogenic micro-organisms from migrating in significant numbers into the gut. Any remaining bacteria is then eliminated by strong hydrochloric acids designed, and specific to carnivores, to create just the right pH (1 to 2) for the inherent enzymes to kill any residual bacteria making their way into the gut.
When the pet’s immune system is healthy, the few bacteria that might survive the high acid content of the stomach will then pass into the small intestine which in a healthy animal contains the naturally occurring digestive enzymes, bicarbonate and bile salts which are deposited by the liver and pancreas. These enzymes are designed to digest the cell walls of any harmful bacteria that may persist and the bile salts from the liver will digest fats (in their natural, raw state) and transport anti- microbial agents. The healthy digestive tract also secretes a potent enzyme called lysozyme which attacks bacterial cell walls. Any bacterium that may survive this arsenal will still need to adhere to the lining of the intestinal wall for illness to occur.
Bacteria naturally and symbiotically exist within the animal’s body and generally do not cause harm. An individual dog’s diet, environment, body chemistry, and immune system will influence their own particular flora balance.
The intestinal flora in a healthy dog is relatively stable. This stability of normal flora actually discourages any infection by outside pathogens such as salmonella and prevents their overgrowth.
A Healthy Diet
When our dogs are fed foods which have been cooked and/or processed (as is the case with commercial pet foods), the live enzymes that are critical to proper digestion and health have been destroyed by the heat of processing actually making them more susceptible to bacterial growth . To decrease the dogâ€™s risk of salmonella related illness, it should be fed a species appropriate, raw diet.
Dogs are opportunistic carnivores requiring a diet of raw meat, organs and bones. We are often asked if raw meat and bones also carry harmful bacteria such as salmonella, and the answer is yes. However, the fact that bacteria are naturally present in raw meat shouldn’t come as any surprise. There is simply no such thing as “bacteria-free” meat. Most of the 10 billion cows, pigs, and birds butchered every year for meat are contaminated with naturally occurring bacteria. It is fairly probable that the meat you bring into your home to feed yourself is potentially as contaminated with bacteria as raw meats fed to pets! For example, salmonella has been identified in samples of ground beef, ground chicken, and ground turkey sold for human consumption.
Meat from healthy animals may become contaminated at slaughter. Meat surfaces become infected with microorganisms associated with food poisoning during handling, packaging, processing, storage, and transportation. Although many procedures have been incorporated into food processing procedures for both the meat and poultry industries to reduce the level of contamination, the fact remains -bacteria persists. All meat products should be considered contaminated at some level. However, this is not an issue for our carnivore companions.
The acidity of the dog’s stomach is designed to kill pathogenic bacteria because it is implicitly designed to process raw meat and bone. Grains, vegetables and other foodstuffs however which are not common to a carnivore’s natural diet will alter the pH of the gut, making it more alkaline. This change in acidity will negatively impact the dog’s ability to destroy potentially harmful bacteria such as salmonella. Protein and fat from animal sources are quickly and easily digested; hence the short digestive system of dogs (and cats). The ability of dogs and cats to secrete hydrochloric acid is also exceptional. To facilitate protein breakdown and kill the bacteria found in decaying meats, dogs and cats are able to keep their gastric pH around 1-2.
Any bacteria surviving the saliva and strong hydrochloric acid in the stomach that make their way into the intestinal tract are also more likely to flourish in a dog that is fed grains. Grains, cooked and processed foods, as well as vegetable matter languish in the intestinal tract much longer than meat protein because carnivores lack the enzymes necessary to break down, digest or properly assimilate any nutrition from these omnivorous foods. In turn, this slow movement in the digestive tract creates an opportunity for harmful bacteria such as salmonella to quickly multiply and create illness.
Finally, dogs that are in poor health and fed poor or inappropriate diets may already have a weakened immune system due to the lack of vital enzymes and live nutrients that would be supplied by a fresh food diet; and this may encourage an increased risk of bacteria related illnesses even though it is quite rare.
The Human Factor
The human intestinal tract does not share anywhere near the same efficiency as the dog’s, so reducing the risk of salmonella related illness is of much greater importance for humans. To reduce salmonella risk in humans, it is necessary to practice good sanitation techniques whenever handling meat for your own consumption as well as feeding dogs, whether it be kibble, treats or even raw meat or poultry products.
Hand-washing after handling pet food, treats, or meats is imperative. In addition, kitchen work surfaces or any utensils used, such as knives, dog dishes, etc., should be washed with a non-toxic, natural anti-bacterial product such as distilled white vinegar, fresh lemon juice, hydrogen peroxide, or grapefruit seed extract.
In conclusion, after taking the necessary precautions for human safety, salmonella should not be an issue for healthy dogs.
Copyright 2003 -2020 This article is the sole property of Dr. Jeanette (Jeannie) Thomason and Dr. Kim Bloomer. It is strictly for educational purposes only. It cannot be reproduced in any form whatsoever without the expressed written consent of both of the authors.
About the Authors
Dr. Jeannie and Dr. Kim are animal naturopaths with doctorates in veterinary naturopathy. Together, they founded the American Council of Animal Naturopathy and the popular, early Podcast – Animal Talk Naturally Radio Show. They also co-authored along with friend and fellow animal naturopath, Dr. Sarah Reagan, the book: Essential Oils in Animal in Animal Care – A Naturopathic Approach.
Both have gone on to write more books and run their own separate online businesses where they offer education, information and consultations – Dr.Jeannie owns – The Whole Dog .org Dr. Bloomer owns – Aspenbloom Pet Care.com
Dr. Jeannie is the founder of the Natural Rearing Breeders Association and considered one of the very few true pioneers in natural rearing
Copyright 2003 -2020 This article is the sole property of Dr. Jeanette (Jeannie) Thomason and Dr. Kim Bloomer. This article is for educational purposes only. It cannot be reproduced in any form whatsoever without the expressed written consent of both of the authors.