MYTH: Raw-Fed Animals Pose a Significant Health Risk To Humans
This is a myth made possible by our society’s pathological fear of bacteria. Of the millions of bacteria on this earth, it is estimated that less than 1% are harmful. Media and society as a whole have played up bacteria, painting it as an evil nemesis that must be stomped out with disinfectants, antibacterial everything, and unnecessary vaccination. This has resulted in the emergence of super-bacteria and “super-viruses”, no thanks to the improper use of antibiotics and the plethora of antibacterial soaps and products. Developmental biologists have recently learned that bacterial exposure is absolutely necessary for the development of a healthy immune system, among other things. Humans and dogs have evolved in the presence of bacteria, and insisting on a sterile environment has created more damage than good. So where does this intersect with raw feeding?
Raw diet critics tout this myth as a main reason for not feeding raw. Yes, there is bacteria in raw meat. Yes, this bacteria can harm you. Yes, this bacteria is sometimes shed in dogs’ feces. So if a raw-fed dog licks you, are you going to get sick? I suppose all things are possible, but on the whole, the answer is: NO, you will not get sick. This bacteria does not persist in the mouth of a raw-fed canine.
Canine (carnivores) saliva contains lysozyme, an enzyme that lyses and destroys bacteria! This is something unique to carnivores – especially canines. So while they lack digestive enzymes to break down and “predigest” vegetables and grains, like we Omnivores do, their mouths are equipped and designed to PREVENT bacteria lingering there. Another important fact is that raw meat, bones and organs do not form plaque on the teeth and gums – the absence of plaque means the dog’s mouth is no longer a hospitable place for bacteria to inhabit. A kibble-fed dog’s mouth, on the other hand, provides the perfect environment for bacteria growth: plaque-covered teeth with sugary and starchy complexes provide both food and shelter for bacteria. The bacteria thrive in the mouth of a kibble-fed dog because it provides both a perfect atmosphere and a good food source (Lonsdale, T. 2001. Raw Meaty Bones.).
Have you ever wondered why kibble-fed dogs have stinky dog breath? Because of the bacteria in their gums and on their teeth (just like the bacteria in our mouths gives us halitosis).
A raw-fed dog’s mouth provides neither food nor a viable atmosphere for bacteria, which is why a raw-fed dog has basically odorless breath. So which dog would you be more worried about being kissed by and contracting disease from? I personally would be quite leery of the stinky-breathed, bacteria-laden kibble-fed dog. If one is still worried about being licked by a raw-fed dog, one has several solutions. Teach the dog not to lick, or avoid being licked. But if you have a healthy immune system, being licked and in contact with a raw-fed dog will not affect you other than boosting your immune system. This is the same thing for babies and young children: being around and licked by a raw-fed dog will do nothing but boost their immune systems and help them grow up into happy, healthy adults. You may not want the dog licking the children right after it finishes up eating and may still have some raw food on it’s lips but as the dog licks its lips, that lysozyme will destroy any bacteria that may remain.
As for dogs shedding bacteria in their feces: common sense here – do not eat dog poo and wash your hands after feeding your dogs or cleaning up after them. Handle the raw meat you feed your dogs just the same way you handle your own raw meat (which can also get you sick if you eat it raw or do not clean up well enough afterward.
Come on, do the so called “experts” really think that people are not smart enough to figure out that they should wash their hands and countertops after preparing raw meaty bones for their dogs? Apparently so. 🙁
Keep dog poop picked up… As soon as the dog poops if possible but at least once a day. If you have children, teach them not to eat dog poo and if you pick up the poo immediately after your dog goes, you will not need to worry.
Bacteria and viruses are absolutely everywhere! Huge numbers live inside of you naturally! In fact, you are just as likely, if not more likely, to get sick from your grocery store vegetables or a strange bathroom. You do not need to worry about the dog tracking bacteria through the house; there is plenty of bacteria throughout the house anyway, so any additional bacteria a raw-fed dog might add is negligible. Thousands of people—even immunocompromised people—feed their dogs raw with no bacteria issues and with stronger immune systems as a result.
Anti-raw people protest that raw-fed dogs pose a serious health risk to immunocompromised people and people with auto-immune disorders. Oddly enough, it is these immunocompromised people who have a better understanding of the important role nutrition plays in strengthening the immune system. A quick tour of some of the social media Raw Feeding groups will reveal quite a few people who have an auto-immune disorder themselves but have been feeding their dogs raw for many years with no ill results whatsoever. Anti-raw people (veterinarians included) make it sound like immuno-compromised people (and most other people) are some how more incapable of properly handling raw meat and cleaning up afterwards. So what do they propose?—do not feed raw meaty bones!—This is absurdly condescending to assume we cannot clean up after ourselves and are incapable of feeding our dogs because we lack a credential in pet nutrition. This proposal to just not feed raw, skips the most logical step: simply observe proper hygiene and use the same precautions you use in preparing your own meat. It is not that difficult, honestly.
Use good hygiene practices: clean countertops and utensils used to feed dogs, and wash your hands. If you or someone in your family is immunocompromised, you can always feed the dog outside or inside on a special towel or plastic-type tablecloth or shower curtain that you can wash after use and re-use. Or feed the dog in its crate, away from the person with the weak immune system.
By training the dog to eat in one particular place, you will not have to “worry” about him tracking a mess or bacteria through the house.
If you are still concerned about bacteria, clean your dog’s paws, mouth, etc. with a mild, safe antimicrobial like diluted white vinegar or diluted Thieves hand soap or Thieves wipes. Honestly, as long as proper hygiene is observed, the bacteria are a non-issue!
For more articles on the risk of salmonella infection and raw fed pets, here are a couple more for you: